Ruby Garcia was 25 years old when Brandon Ortiz-Vite shot and killed her in Grand Rapids in March 2024. ICE had deported him to Mexico in 2020, but he returned to the United States illegally. Imagine how Ruby’s family and friends must feel hearing Grand Rapids Mayor David LaGrand tell the city commission that he doesn’t welcome ICE in their community.
Ortiz-Vite pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and is now serving a 39-to-102-year prison sentence in Michigan. He later sued President Trump over Trump’s public comments about the case, demanding $75 million, a public apology and U.S. citizenship. A federal judge dismissed his lawsuit.
Ruby Garcia deserved to live. If Ortiz-Vite had been kept from returning after ICE deported him, Ruby would still be alive. That’s why I want Democrats to let ICE do its job.
Here’s what LaGrand told the city commission about ICE.
“I do not consider them welcome in our community. I do not welcome them in our community.”
LaGrand is talking about the very agency that deported Ortiz-Vite years before he killed Ruby. Ruby was part of that community, too.
LaGrand then laid out his immigration plan. His first step would be to give work visas to everyone already here and working. His second would offer a path to citizenship. The most troubling part of LaGrand’s plan is his third step.
“Any two random Americans could fix this if you put them in a room for half an hour. It’s not complicated. All we need to do is essentially give work visas to everybody who’s already here and working. Step one.”
His third step goes further. LaGrand said a job offer from an American employer should be enough for someone overseas to get a visa.
“And step 3, a very robust and generous visa entry program that doesn’t depend on you having a PhD or credentials, but simply says if, if an American employer wants you to come and do work in America, you can get a visa. And we don’t put constrictions on it. That’s the solution.”
LaGrand even claimed almost every American would come up with the same plan.
“And I can tell you 350 million people would basically come up with that same solution if you stuck two of them in a room together. This is not hard.”
I’m one American who disagrees. LaGrand laid out three steps. Not one called for employers to offer those jobs to Americans first. Not one addressed how his plan would keep murderers, rapists, drunk drivers, armed robbers, child predators, human traffickers, drug cartel members, and terrorists from entering the country on work visas.
American workers deserve a fair shot at those jobs and a wage they can live on. Companies should raise wages before recruiting overseas for less. LaGrand told us exactly what he’d do for the employer who wants to hire from overseas. He had nothing to say to the American who wants that same job.
Watch on YouTube
Watch on Rumble
@WallStreetApes posted this video on X.
